Mexican journalist fights to keep state protection after years of threats
Alberto Amaro and others describe gaps in the federal safety program that has failed to prevent killings and often delays aid.
By Hiroshi Gupta ·

Alberto Amaro, a 38-year-old reporter in Tlaxcala, is battling to retain the security measures assigned to his family after federal authorities attempted to withdraw them. Amaro founded the digital news outlet La Prensa de Tlaxcala in 2019 and joined the federal Protection Mechanism for Human Rights Defenders and Journalists the same year. Since then, he has endured more than 30 violent or menacing incidents, including death threats, detention, and gunfire linked to his reporting on police and organized crime.
The federal agency that oversees the protection program is facing scrutiny for its reactive approach. A joint investigation by Amnesty International and the Committee to Protect Journalists found that eight journalists were killed while enrolled in the mechanism between 2017 and 2022. Vanessa Carrillo, codirector of the civil society group Propuesta Cívica, stated that the system suffers from bureaucratic delays and insufficient staffing. She argued that the mechanism is given a responsibility that belongs to the state as a whole rather than functioning as a preventive tool.
In 2023, the agency classified Amaro as high risk and assigned him bodyguards after he reported direct death threats from a local mayor. Despite acknowledging his high risk status, the agency later sought to remove his protection. Amaro took the case to court, where a judge ordered a comprehensive risk assessment. He described the constant anxiety of his role, noting that he worries about being killed while leaving home or returning that day. He also worries about the administrative process of keeping his protection measures in place.
The challenges faced by Amaro mirror the experiences of other journalists and their families in Mexico. Priscila Pacheco, 34, has spent over a decade seeking justice and safety after her father, Francisco Pacheco, was shot dead outside their home in Taxco in 2016. Her father reported on local government corruption for the outlet El Foro de Taxco. The killing remains unsolved, and the family was displaced for years. Pacheco said the mechanism denied her personal protection because she works as a public employee. She noted that their panic button often fails and security equipment at their home is poorly maintained.
Jonathan Cuevas, 38, experienced displacement from his home in Iguala for three years due to threats related to his reporting. In 2020, the protection agency placed him in a safe house in Mexico City. He was moved between three such facilities before returning to Iguala in 2023 after a truce between rival criminal groups. Cuevas said his return was not the result of government action. After returning, two people warned him to stop publishing stories about the local prosecutor’s office. He eventually stopped reporting on those issues and noted that the agency documented his attacks but failed to coordinate with federal prosecutors.
Cuevas refused bodyguards, arguing that moving with armed men made him an easier target. He criticized the system for prioritizing safe houses over allowing journalists to continue working in their communities. He pointed out that his panic button does not function in areas without cell service, a common location for his reporting. He asked what happens to those who want to keep practicing journalism while facing such obstacles.
President Claudia Sheinbaum stated in 2025 that the protection mechanism could receive additional funding if needed. However, Reporters Without Borders says the government has made little progress in fulfilling press freedom commitments, including a promised review of the program. The Associated Press contacted the federal agency multiple times for an interview. A senior official declined to speak, and the agency did not respond to later requests.
Amaro spent a year in Spain with his family due to threats. A recent assessment classified him as high risk but determined his family was not. Authorities sought to withdraw his family’s bodyguards and restrict their movements in 2025. Amaro challenged these decisions in court and won. Recently, he received a call from an unknown number where the caller claimed to be a senior operative with the Jalisco New Generation Cartel and warned him to watch what he writes. Despite having two bodyguards around the clock, Amaro said he does not feel safe, noting that if he encounters four people, they have already beaten them.






