AdvertiseDonate
New YorkJersey CityNewarkBostonPhiladelphiaBaltimoreWashingtonBuffalo
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Headlines from coast to coast.
Newz Analysis · 157 Church Street, 19th floor, New Haven, CT 06510
Business · Long Island

Sag Harbor Real Estate: Three Homes One Price Tag

A 12.9 million dollar listing in the historic village core includes a Georgian house, a shingled retreat, and a newly approved accessory dwelling unit.

By Adrian Salazar ·

Illustration for: Sag Harbor Real Estate: Three Homes One Price Tag
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A rare real estate package just hit the market in Sag Harbor.

The CeeJackTeam at Compass is offering a compound called the Captain’s Compound for 12.9 million dollars. The property combines two separate residential addresses with a historic barn. It sits in the heart of the historic village core. Listing agent Jack Pearson says estates of this scale are almost never available on these specific lanes.

The main residence at 9 Suffolk Street is a Georgian style home built in the 1800s. It features 3,400 square feet of living space with five bedrooms and four bathrooms. The house retains original historic millwork and six by six windows. It includes five distinct living spaces with original fireplaces. The updated kitchen opens to a family room and two patios. The backyard contains a heated gunite pool, a feature Pearson notes is rare in the historic district.

The second property at 12 Amity Street sits directly adjacent to the pool. This shingled home provides 1,500 square feet with three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms. It has a covered front porch and a bright kitchen with a center island. A door leads from the kitchen to a deck and outdoor shower. The lower level holds a recreational room and laundry area. Together, the two houses offer nine bedrooms and nearly 5,000 square feet of total living space.

The compound also includes a historic barn at the rear of the property. This structure covers a tenth of an acre. It recently received accessory dwelling unit status, making it a legal dwelling. Designs are in place for a new full bathroom, powder room, and kitchen. The barn can accommodate an additional bedroom. Pearson describes it as a natural connector between the two addresses. The property has off street parking for up to four cars at the main house and two more spaces for the second address.

The total land area for the main property is 0.17 acres. The listing emphasizes the privacy of a private compound with the walkability of village life. The homes were restored to keep their historic character while adding modern comforts. The price of 12.9 million dollars covers the two residences and the approved barn unit.

More Business · Scam Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Newz Analysis in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. UFC 2026 schedule highlights: Prochazka seeks redemption against Stirling in Qatar
  2. 21 Curated Holiday Gift Ideas for Father
  3. Chinese scientist fired after hiding death of child in gene therapy trial
  4. Hedge Fund CEO Outlines Seven Strategic Triggers for Selling Stock Positions
  5. Russian forces aim to cut off Zaporizhzhia before advancing on Dnipro, Ukrainian corps commander says
Get Newz Analysis in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.